← All lessons

Adjective Clause: Defining and Non-Defining

💡 What is an Adjective Clause? Like an Adjective, an Adjective Clause modifies a Noun.[span_318](start_span)[span_318](end_span) An Adjective is generally placed before a Noun or after a linking verb, but an Adjective Clause is always placed after the Noun (its Antecedent) that it modifies.[span_319](start_span)[span_319](end_span)

📘 Part 1: Fundamental Rules of Adjective Clauses

📌 Key Characteristics of an Adjective Clause

  1. 1. Like an Adjective, an Adjective Clause also modifies a Noun.[span_320](start_span)[span_320](end_span) An Adjective is generally placed before a Noun or after a linking verb.[span_321](start_span)[span_321](end_span) But an Adjective Clause is always placed after the Noun.[span_322](start_span)[span_322](end_span)
  2. 2. Certain Relative Pronouns are used in an Adjective Clause.[span_323](start_span)[span_323](end_span) Those Relative Pronouns can be in three forms: Subject, Object, and Possessive.[span_324](start_span)[span_324](end_span)
  3. 3. There is an Antecedent before an Adjective Clause.[span_325](start_span)[span_325](end_span)
  4. 4. An Adjective Clause generally begins with who, which, that, whom, whose, of which as Relative Pronouns and why, where, when, how, as, etc. as Relative Adverbs.[span_326](start_span)[span_326](end_span) However, when a Relative Pronoun works as the object of a transitive verb in an Adjective Clause, it can be omitted.[span_327](start_span)[span_327](end_span)

📊 The Forms of Relative Pronouns Are as Follows:

Category Subject Form Object Form Possessive Form
For Persons[span_328](start_span)[span_328](end_span) who, that[span_329](start_span)[span_329](end_span) whom / who, that[span_330](start_span)[span_330](end_span) whose[span_331](start_span)[span_331](end_span)
For Things[span_332](start_span)[span_332](end_span) which, that[span_333](start_span)[span_333](end_span) which, that[span_334](start_span)[span_334](end_span) whose / of which[span_335](start_span)[span_335](end_span)
Example:
This is the boy who stood first.[span_336](start_span)[span_336](end_span)
🔍 Explanation: who stood first is an Adjective Clause because it modifies "the boy" used as its antecedent, and according to the rule, it sits after the noun "the boy".[span_337](start_span)[span_337](end_span)
💡 Note — Antecedent: The previously mentioned Noun or Pronoun to which a Relative Pronoun refers is called an Antecedent (Ante = before; cedent = going).[span_338](start_span)[span_338](end_span)

📗 Part 2: Classification of Adjective Clauses by Form & Position

According to the form and position of the Relative Pronoun, Adjective Clauses have been divided into several categories:[span_339](start_span)[span_339](end_span)

📌 (i) Adjective Clause with Relative Pronoun as Subject

In this case, the Subjective form of the Relative Pronoun (who, which, that) is used as the Subject of the Adjective Clause.[span_340](start_span)[span_340](end_span)

Examples:
1. Jerry was a poor boy who lived in the orphanage.[span_341](start_span)[span_341](end_span)
🔍 Explanation: In the sentence above, who lived in the orphanage is an Adjective Clause because the Relative Pronoun who is in the Subject position and before it, "boy" is placed as the Antecedent of who.[span_342](start_span)[span_342](end_span) Note that the Adjective Clause who lived in the orphanage modifies the Noun "boy".[span_343](start_span)[span_343](end_span)

2. I bought a pen which was black.[span_344](start_span)[span_344](end_span)
3. The writer took a cabin that was small.[span_345](start_span)[span_345](end_span)
💡 Note: As a Relative Pronoun, who is placed for persons, which for things or lower animals, and that for all—persons, things, and animals.[span_346](start_span)[span_346](end_span)

Placing the Adjective Clause in the Middle of the Main Clause:

An Adjective Clause can also be placed in the middle of the Main Clause:[span_347](start_span)[span_347](end_span)

Example:
The lady who ate many items was greedy.[span_348](start_span)[span_348](end_span)
🔍 Explanation: who ate many items is an Adjective Clause because according to the rule it is placed between the Subject "The lady" and the predicate "was greedy" of the Principal Clause.[span_349](start_span)[span_349](end_span) Besides, the subjective relative pronoun 'who' sits as the Subject of the Adjective Clause and modifies its preceding Antecedent "The lady".[span_350](start_span)[span_350](end_span) We know that an Adjective Clause sits after a Noun, and here too the Adjective Clause is placed right after the Noun "The lady".[span_351](start_span)[span_351](end_span)

More Examples:
• The writer who was poor could not taste caviare.[span_352](start_span)[span_352](end_span)
• The porter who was a young bachelor lived in the city of Baghdad.[span_353](start_span)[span_353](end_span)
• The pen which was given to him was costly.[span_354](start_span)[span_354](end_span)
• The shirt that was bought was costly.[span_355](start_span)[span_355](end_span)

📌 (ii) Adjective Clause with Relative Pronoun as Object

In this case, the objective form of the Relative Pronoun (whom, which, that) sits as the object of the Adjective Clause, and it is placed before the subject of the Adjective Clause.[span_356](start_span)[span_356](end_span)

Example:
The boy whom we helped was very helpless.[span_357](start_span)[span_357](end_span)
🔍 Explanation: In the sentence above, whom we helped is an Adjective Clause because according to the rule it is placed after the Noun "The boy" used as its Antecedent.[span_358](start_span)[span_358](end_span) Moreover, the objective form "whom" of the Relative Pronoun sits as the object of the Adjective Clause and is placed before the Subject "we".[span_359](start_span)[span_359](end_span)
💡 Note (Omitting the Relative Pronoun): When a Relative Pronoun works as the object of a transitive verb in an Adjective Clause, it can be omitted.[span_360](start_span)[span_360](end_span)
• Example: This is the book (which) I bought yesterday.[span_361](start_span)[span_361](end_span)
• In the sentence above, 'which' works as the object of the transitive verb "bought" in the Adjective Clause.[span_362](start_span)[span_362](end_span)

📌 (iii) Adjective Clause with Relative Pronoun as Object of Preposition

  1. In this case, the Relative Pronoun works as the object of a preposition.[span_363](start_span)[span_363](end_span) (Note that in such cases, the relative pronoun placed after the preposition works as the object of that preposition.)[span_364](start_span)[span_364](end_span)
  2. Preposition + that object is placed before the Subject of the Adjective Clause.[span_365](start_span)[span_365](end_span)
Example 1:
This is the boy about whom I told you.[span_366](start_span)[span_366](end_span)
🔍 Explanation: In the sentence above, about whom I told you is an Adjective Clause because according to the rule it works as the object of about after the Preposition "about".[span_367](start_span)[span_367](end_span) Furthermore, when an Adjective Clause sits with the object of a preposition, it is placed before the subject of the Adjective Clause, and here too about whom (preposition + object) is placed before the Subject "I" of the Adjective Clause.[span_368](start_span)[span_368](end_span)

More Examples:
• The flat in which they live is very gorgeous.[span_369](start_span)[span_369](end_span)
• The man to whom I gave the news was very reliable.[span_370](start_span)[span_370](end_span)
💡 Note: In many cases, the Relative Pronoun can be omitted and the preposition can be placed after the verb:[span_371](start_span)[span_371](end_span)
• The flat they live in is very gorgeous.[span_372](start_span)[span_372](end_span)
• This is the boy I told you about.[span_373](start_span)[span_373](end_span)

📌 (iv) Adjective Clause with Relative Pronoun as Possessive

  1. In this case, the possessive form of the Relative Pronoun (whose / of which) is used.[span_374](start_span)[span_374](end_span)
  2. The possessive form of the Relative Pronoun is placed after the Noun used as the Antecedent.[span_375](start_span)[span_375](end_span)
Example 1:
The boy whose pen was lost was poor.[span_376](start_span)[span_376](end_span)
🔍 Explanation: In the sentence above, 'whose pen was lost' is an Adjective Clause because it begins with the possessive form "whose" of the Relative Pronoun and is placed after the noun the boy used as the Antecedent.[span_377](start_span)[span_377](end_span)

More Examples:
• The man whose pocket was picked fell into trouble.[span_378](start_span)[span_378](end_span)
• The building whose roof was repaired is not suitable to live in.[span_379](start_span)[span_379](end_span)
• He has a house whose colour is white.[span_380](start_span)[span_380](end_span)
💡 Note:
(i) The Relative Pronoun "Whose" is applicable to all—persons, things, and animals.[span_381](start_span)[span_381](end_span)
(ii) In the case of things and animals, of which can be used instead of whose:[span_382](start_span)[span_382](end_span)
• The building, the roof of which was repaired, is not suitable to live in.[span_383](start_span)[span_383](end_span)

📌 (v) Adjective Clause with Relative Adverb

In this case, where, why, when, as, how are used as Relative Adverbs in the Adjective Clause:[span_384](start_span)[span_384](end_span)

  1. (i) Those Relative Adverbs are placed at the beginning of the Adjective Clause.[span_385](start_span)[span_385](end_span)
  2. (ii) Like Relative Pronouns, Relative Adverbs modify the Noun used as the Antecedent.[span_386](start_span)[span_386](end_span)
Example:
I know the place where he lives.[span_387](start_span)[span_387](end_span)
🔍 Explanation: In the sentence above, where he lives is an Adjective Clause because where is used here as a Relative Adverb and modifies its Antecedent "the place".[span_388](start_span)[span_388](end_span) Furthermore, the Adjective Clause begins with the Relative Adverb according to the rule.[span_389](start_span)[span_389](end_span)
Relative Adverb (Adjective Clause — Has Antecedent) Conjunctive Adverb (Noun Clause — No Antecedent)
I know the place where he lives.[span_390](start_span)[span_390](end_span) I know where he lives.[span_391](start_span)[span_391](end_span)
Can you tell me the time when he will come?[span_392](start_span)[span_392](end_span) Can you tell me when he will come?[span_393](start_span)[span_393](end_span)

📙 Part 3: Special Adjective Clauses ("But", "The same…as/that", "Such…as")

📌 1. Adjective Clause with "But" as Relative Pronoun

In this case, from but to the end is the Adjective Clause, and the remaining part is the Principal Clause:[span_394](start_span)[span_394](end_span)

• There is no mother but loves her child.[span_395](start_span)[span_395](end_span)
• There is none but wishes to be happy.[span_396](start_span)[span_396](end_span)

📌 2. Adjective Clause with "The same — as / that"

In this case, from the beginning of the given sentence up to before as/that is the Principal Clause, and from as/that to the end is the Subordinate Adjective Clause.[span_397](start_span)[span_397](end_span) For example:

• This is the same book as (or, that) I lost.[span_398](start_span)[span_398](end_span)

📌 3. Adjective Clause with "Such — as"

In this case, from the beginning of the given sentence up to before as is the Principal Clause, and from as to the end is the Subordinate Adjective Clause.[span_399](start_span)[span_399](end_span) For example:

• We want such boys as are honest.[span_400](start_span)[span_400](end_span)

📒 Part 4: Defining Relative Clause

📌 Rules & Characteristics of Defining Relative Clauses

  1. (i) This kind of Clause restricts or narrows down the limit of the Noun used before it as an Antecedent.[span_401](start_span)[span_401](end_span)
  2. (ii) This kind of Clause generally begins with who, which, that.[span_402](start_span)[span_402](end_span) who is placed for persons, and which and that for things or lower animals.[span_403](start_span)[span_403](end_span)
  3. (iii) Generally, the + Noun is used before a Defining Relative Clause.[span_404](start_span)[span_404](end_span) However, a/an + Noun can be used instead of the + noun.[span_405](start_span)[span_405](end_span) Note that if the Noun used as the Antecedent is plural, the is not placed before that Noun.[span_406](start_span)[span_406](end_span) Besides Nouns, pronouns such as all, none, anybody, somebody, etc., and those are placed as Antecedents.[span_407](start_span)[span_407](end_span) In this case, the Nouns or pronouns are used as the object of a verb or preposition.[span_408](start_span)[span_408](end_span)
Examples:
1. The boy who came here is my brother.[span_409](start_span)[span_409](end_span)
2. I saw somebody who was walking beside the lake.[span_410](start_span)[span_410](end_span)
🔍 Explanation:
• In the first sentence above, who came here restricts the limit of the Noun "the boy".[span_411](start_span)[span_411](end_span) Moreover, the Clause begins with 'who' according to the rule and sits after the Noun "boy" used as the Antecedent.[span_412](start_span)[span_412](end_span)
• In the second sentence, who was walking beside the lake is a Defining Relative Clause because the Pronoun "somebody" is placed before it as an Antecedent.[span_413](start_span)[span_413](end_span) In a Defining Relative Clause, a pronoun used as an Antecedent is used as the object of the verb of the Principal Clause. Here, the pronoun "somebody" is used as the object after the verb "saw".[span_414](start_span)[span_414](end_span)

More Examples:
• The story is about a boy who is an orphan.[span_415](start_span)[span_415](end_span)
• The stone that he threw hit the boy seriously.[span_416](start_span)[span_416](end_span)
• The pen which he bought writes well.[span_417](start_span)[span_417](end_span)
💡 Note: Often a Defining Relative Clause can be separated from the Noun or Pronoun used as its Antecedent by a word or phrase:[span_418](start_span)[span_418](end_span)
• Example: I saw a man in the street who was begging.[span_419](start_span)[span_419](end_span)
• Explanation: Here, the Defining Relative Clause who was begging has been separated from its Antecedent "a man" by using the phrase "in the street".[span_420](start_span)[span_420](end_span)

📕 Part 5: Non-Defining Relative Clause

📌 Rules & Characteristics of Non-Defining Relative Clauses

  1. (i) A Non-Defining Relative Clause does not restrict the limit of the Noun used before it as an Antecedent; it is used only to lengthen the Sentence (or provide extra information).[span_421](start_span)[span_421](end_span)
  2. (ii) At the beginning of this kind of Clause, who, which are used as Subject; whom, which as Object; and whose, of which as Possessive.[span_422](start_span)[span_422](end_span)
  3. (iii) This kind of Clause is not essential to the Sentence, so it can be omitted from the Sentence.[span_423](start_span)[span_423](end_span)
  4. (iv) The Clause is separated from the Noun used as the Antecedent by placing Commas (,).[span_424](start_span)[span_424](end_span)
  5. (v) The Pronoun cannot be omitted in this kind of Clause.[span_425](start_span)[span_425](end_span)
Example:
Our headmaster, who is a very learned man, teaches us English.[span_426](start_span)[span_426](end_span)
🔍 Explanation: Here, who is a very learned man is a Non-Defining Clause because instead of restricting the Noun used as the Antecedent (Our headmaster), it expands upon it.[span_427](start_span)[span_427](end_span) Moreover, if that Clause is omitted from the main Sentence, no harm is done to the meaning of the Sentence.[span_428](start_span)[span_428](end_span) According to the rule, the Clause begins with who and is separated from the main Sentence by placing Commas before and after it.[span_429](start_span)[span_429](end_span)

More Examples:
• The boy, who had been reading all day long, grew tired.[span_430](start_span)[span_430](end_span)
• The shirt, which my father bought for me, suits me well.[span_431](start_span)[span_431](end_span)
• The boy, whose pen was lost on the way, is very poor.[span_432](start_span)[span_432](end_span)
💡 Note: A Non-Defining Relative Clause can also sit with the object of a Preposition:[span_433](start_span)[span_433](end_span)
• His car, for which he spent 50,000 taka, is now out of order.[span_434](start_span)[span_434](end_span)

📘 Part 6: Connective Relative Clauses & Cleft Sentences

📌 Connective Relative Clause

  1. (i) In this Clause, the pronouns who, whom, whose, which are used.[span_435](start_span)[span_435](end_span)
  2. (ii) Instead of describing the Noun used before it, this Clause helps to extend the Sentence (continuing the narrative).[span_436](start_span)[span_436](end_span)
  3. (iii) This Clause is placed after the Object of the Verb of the Main Clause or after Preposition + Noun.[span_437](start_span)[span_437](end_span)
  4. (iv) A Comma (,) is placed before this Clause.[span_438](start_span)[span_438](end_span)
Examples:
• I told Rahman, who informed it was not his duty.[span_439](start_span)[span_439](end_span)
• I gave the book to Rahim, who gave it to Anis.[span_440](start_span)[span_440](end_span)

📌 Cleft Sentences with Defining Clause

  1. (i) First, It is placed +[span_441](start_span)[span_441](end_span)
  2. (ii) "Be verb" is placed +[span_442](start_span)[span_442](end_span)
  3. (iii) Noun / pronoun is placed +[span_443](start_span)[span_443](end_span)
  4. (iv) The Defining Relative Clause is placed.[span_444](start_span)[span_444](end_span)
📐 Structure: It + Be verb + Noun/Pronoun + Defining Relative Clause.[span_445](start_span)[span_445](end_span)
Examples:
• It was Jerry who steadied the loose stone.[span_446](start_span)[span_446](end_span)
• It is you who have taken the pen.[span_447](start_span)[span_447](end_span)

✍️ Exercise: Find Out the Adjective Clauses in the Following Sentences

Identify the Adjective Clause and its Antecedent in each of the following 15 sentences (Click on "Show Answer" to check your solution):[span_448](start_span)[span_448](end_span)

  1. I know the boy who has done the work.[span_449](start_span)[span_449](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "who has done the work" (Antecedent: 'the boy')

  2. This is the house that I want to buy.[span_450](start_span)[span_450](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "that I want to buy" (Antecedent: 'the house')

  3. I ate the mangoes which you gave me.[span_451](start_span)[span_451](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "which you gave me" (Antecedent: 'the mangoes')

  4. We want such men as are honest.[span_452](start_span)[span_452](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "as are honest" (Antecedent: 'such men')

  5. The house in which we live is small.[span_453](start_span)[span_453](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "in which we live" (Antecedent: 'The house')

  6. Do you know the boy who came here yesterday?[span_454](start_span)[span_454](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "who came here yesterday" (Antecedent: 'the boy')

  7. The lady who ate many items was greedy.[span_455](start_span)[span_455](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "who ate many items" (Antecedent: 'The lady')

  8. The shirt that was bought was costly.[span_456](start_span)[span_456](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "that was bought" (Antecedent: 'The shirt')

  9. The porter who was a young bachelor lived in the city of Baghdad.[span_457](start_span)[span_457](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "who was a young bachelor" (Antecedent: 'The porter')

  10. The writer took the cabin which belonged to the orphanage.[span_458](start_span)[span_458](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "which belonged to the orphanage" (Antecedent: 'the cabin')

  11. I know the reason why he kept silent.[span_459](start_span)[span_459](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "why he kept silent" (Antecedent: 'the reason')

  12. He is the man who is very rich.[span_460](start_span)[span_460](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "who is very rich" (Antecedent: 'the man')

  13. There is no man but wishes to be happy.[span_461](start_span)[span_461](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "but wishes to be happy" (Antecedent: 'man')

  14. Jerry who was an honest boy could not take the money.[span_462](start_span)[span_462](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "who was an honest boy" (Antecedent: 'Jerry')

  15. Do you know the boy who came yesterday?[span_463](start_span)[span_463](end_span)
    Show Answer

    Adjective Clause: "who came yesterday" (Antecedent: 'the boy')