← All lessons

Relative and Interrogative Pronouns: Who, Whom, Which, That

Relative and Interrogative Pronouns: Who, Whom, Which, That

Understand how Relative Pronouns connect clauses to antecedents and how Interrogative Pronouns form direct and indirect questions in English.

1. Relative Pronouns & Antecedents

The prefix "Re" means back and "lative" means relation. Therefore, a Pronoun that sits after a previously mentioned Noun, establishes a relation with it, and at the same time joins two sentences together is called a Relative Pronoun.

  1. I saw the fisherman. He was catching fish.
    = I saw the fisherman who was catching fish.
  2. This is the house. I want to buy it.
    = This is the house which/that I want to buy.
  3. We helped the girl. Her father died last year.
    = We helped the girl whose father died last year.
  4. The man is a famous doctor. I met him in the bus.
    = The man whom I met in the bus is a famous doctor.

Explanation: In the sentences above, who, which/that, whose, and whom are Relative Pronouns because they sit after the fisherman, the house, the girl, and the man respectively, join the two sentences together, and point back to the previously mentioned Noun.

What is an Antecedent?
The previously mentioned Noun to which a Relative Pronoun refers is called its Antecedent (Ante = before; cedent = that which goes). In the sentences above, who, which/that, whose, and whom are Relative Pronouns, and fisherman, house, girl, and man are their respective Antecedents.

Two Functions of a Relative Pronoun:
  1. Like a Demonstrative Pronoun, it points to a preceding Noun and establishes a relation with it.
  2. Like a Conjunction, it joins two sentences together.

Note: When the Antecedent of a Relative Pronoun is omitted (understood), it simply joins two Clauses like a Conjunction. In that case, it is called a Conjunctive Pronoun.
Example: I know who did the work.

2. Principal Relative Pronouns & Their Uses

The principal Relative Pronouns are Who, which, that, and what. In addition, as and but are also used as Relative Pronouns.

(a) Who, Whose, and Whom

  • Who (Nominative): Used when the Pronoun refers to a person (such as I, we, you, they, he, she).
    Example: I met a man. He is a teacher. → I met a man who is a teacher.
    The Objective form of who is whom, and the Possessive form is whose.
  • Whose (Possessive): Used in place of a Possessive Pronoun/Adjective (my, our, your, their, his, her).
    Example: The boy was very poor. His pen was lost. → The boy whose pen was lost was very poor.
    Note: The Relative Pronoun whose is applicable to inanimate things as well as persons:
    Example: The book whose leaves are torn has been replaced.
    Alternatively, of which can be written instead of whose for things:
    Example: The book, the leaves of which are torn, has been replaced.
  • Whom (Objective): Used in place of an Objective Pronoun (me, us, you, them, him, her).
    Example: The man is a famous doctor. I met him in the bus. → The man whom I met in the bus is a famous doctor.

(b) Which

Used when the antecedent is an inanimate object, a young child, or a lower animal (such as pen, pencil, dog, house, etc.).

  • The writer took a cabin. It belonged to the orphanage.
    → The writer took a cabin which belonged to the orphanage.
  • In the Possessive Case, of which is used:
    Example: This is the book of which I told you.

(c) What & Compound Relatives

What is used only to refer to things. It is formed by combining that and which—meaning what = that which / the thing which / the things which. For this reason, what is called a Compound Relative. The antecedent of what always remains omitted (understood).

  • You say something. It is true. → What you say is true.

Compound Relatives with -ever or -soever: Compound Relatives are also formed by adding ever or soever to who, which, and what:

  • Whoever / whosoever you are, I do not care.
  • You cannot do whichever / whichsoever you want.
  • Give him whatever / whatsoever he needs.

(d) That

That is sometimes used in place of who, whom, or which, but it is never used in place of whose. That is used for both persons and things, and it has no Possessive form.

  • This is the woman. She lost her bag. → This is the woman that (= who) lost her bag.
  • These are books. The books have just arrived. → These are books that (= which) have just arrived.
  • The man was not poor at all. We helped the man. → The man that (= whom) we helped was not poor at all.
"That" is generally used in the following 6 cases:
  1. After an Adjective in the Superlative Degree:
    He is the best boy that I ever saw.
  2. After All, the same, any, and only:
    All that he said was not true.
    This is the same person that I met yesterday.
    Anybody that does not work hard cannot shine in life.
    The only pen that I bought is lost.
  3. After Interrogative Pronouns like Who and What:
    Who is there that does not feel for his country?
    What is that to you?
  4. In Negative Sentences:
    No person that is not industrious can succeed in life.
  5. After two Antecedents where one denotes a person and the other denotes a thing or animal:
    The men and things that he came across have been written in a diary.
  6. After an Ordinal Numeral Adjective:
    Hazrat Abu Bakar (R) was the first man that put faith in Islam.

(e) But (Negative Relative)

But is used as a Relative Pronoun to express the meaning of "that...not" / "who...not". It is called a Negative Relative.

  • There is no rose but has a thorn. (= There is no rose that does not have a thorn.)

(f) As

As a Relative Pronoun, as is always used after such, the same, as many, as much, and as/so:

  • We want such boys as are honest.
  • He ate as many mangoes as he could.
  • The feather is as white as milk.
  • Nothing is so useful as iron.
Notes on "As":
  1. When the Verb after the same is omitted (understood), as must be used. When the Verb after the same is expressed, either as or that may be used:
    • This is the same pen as that.
    • This is the same pen as (that) I want.
  2. When as is used as a Relative Pronoun, it refers to both persons and things. However, when it is used as a Conjunctive Adverb (e.g., I shall come back as soon as I can), it is not a Relative Pronoun.

3. Other Uses of "Who" and "Which"

1. Restrictive Use of "Who" and "Which"

When who and which restrict or narrow down the limit of a Noun like an Adjective, their use is called Restrictive Use.

  • The man who came here yesterday is a famous doctor.
  • The pen which he gave me was black.

In the two sentences above, who and which narrow down the general nouns man and pen to one specific man and one specific pen. A Clause introduced by a Restrictive who or which is an Adjective Clause.

2. Continuative Use of "Who" and "Which"

When who and which do not restrict the limit of the Noun, but are used simply to continue or lengthen the sentence, their use is called Continuative Use. In this sense, who = and he/she and which = and it.

  • He met his friend, who (i.e., and he) gave him a book.
  • He visited Chittagong, which (i.e., and it) is the biggest sea port of Bangladesh.

Notes:
(a) When a Relative Pronoun is used in a Restrictive sense, no comma is placed before it. When it is used in a Continuative sense, a comma is generally placed before it.
(b) In Continuative use, who and which can be replaced by a Conjunction (and) + a Pronoun (he/she/it), whereas in Restrictive use this cannot be done.

3. Adverbial Use of "Who" and "Which"

Sometimes who and which are used in such a way that they express Cause or Purpose. This type of usage is called Adverbial Use:

  • The boy who (= because he) was found irregular was punished. (Cause)
  • He has sent me a book which (= that it may) will help me to learn a lot. (Purpose)

Rule on "and / but" before "which": Since a Relative Pronoun already acts as a Conjunction, and or but is not placed before which—except when joining two Adjective Clauses that share the same antecedent:
• I have seen the book which you have written and which is very useful.
• I have seen the portrait of Monalisa which is very mysterious, but which is very lifelike.

4. Rules of Antecedents, Omission & Conjunctive Pronouns

  1. Position of Antecedent: The Antecedent is always placed immediately before the Relative Pronoun.
    Example: I bought a pen which was black.
  2. Possessive Noun/Pronoun cannot be an Antecedent: A Noun or Pronoun in the Possessive Case can never be the Antecedent of a Relative Pronoun. Instead, the Noun must be made the Object of the preposition of:
    Incorrect: I like Shakespeare's plays who is a famous dramatist.
    Correct: I like the plays of Shakespeare who is a famous dramatist.
  3. "Those" instead of "They" as Antecedent: The Antecedent of a Relative Pronoun is those, not they:
    Incorrect: They who waste time in idleness cannot prosper in life.
    Correct: Those who waste time in idleness cannot prosper in life.
  4. Agreement with Antecedent: The Number, Person, and Gender of a Relative Pronoun (and its following Verb) are determined by the Number, Person, and Gender of its Antecedent:
    Incorrect: It is I who has done the work.
    Correct: It is I who have done the work.
  5. A Clause cannot be the Antecedent of a Relative Pronoun: A whole Clause can never serve as the Antecedent of a Relative Pronoun. Instead of a Relative Pronoun, "and this" or "and that" should be used:
    Incorrect: You kill your time which is unwanted.
    Correct: You kill your time and this is unwanted.
    Incorrect: You topped the list which pleased us all.
    Correct: You topped the list and that pleased us all.

Omission of the Relative Pronoun

In the Objective Case, the Relative Pronoun may be omitted (left understood):

  • The pen (which/that) I gave you was black.
  • He is the man (whom) I met in the college.

Conjunctive Pronoun

We know that a Relative Pronoun establishes a relation with a preceding Noun and joins two sentences like a Conjunction. However, when the preceding Noun (Antecedent) is omitted, the Pronoun only joins two sentences together and is called a Conjunctive Pronoun.

  • This is what he said.

Note: When the Antecedent of a Relative Pronoun is omitted, the Clause introduced by it is a Noun Clause.

5. Interrogative Pronouns: Who, Whom, Whose, What & Which

A Pronoun that is used to ask a question is called an Interrogative Pronoun.

  • What do you want?
  • Who did the work?
  • Which is your brother?
  • Whom did you meet yesterday?
  • Whose is this pen?

Note: Who, which, and what look like Relative Pronouns in form, but they differ in function. When they are used to ask questions, they are called Interrogative Pronouns.

Uses of Interrogative Pronouns:

(a) Who, Whom, and Whose

Who is used indefinitely for persons only in both Singular and Plural Numbers:
Example: Who is knocking at the door? (It is unknown who is knocking at the door.)

Forms of "Who" in Different Cases:

Nominative (Subject) Objective (Object) Possessive
Who Whom Whose

Examples: Whose watch is this? Whom do you want?

(b) What

  1. For things only (in both Singular and Plural Numbers):
    What is your name?
  2. Exclamatory "What": When the Interrogative Pronoun What is used to express wonder or surprise in the sense of "how great / how much", it is called an Exclamatory What:
    What a fine bird it is!
  3. "What not" (in the sense of "and so many other things"): Used after a list of nouns or verbs:
    He bought pens, papers, books and what not.
    They sang, shouted, laughed and what not.
  4. "What...for" (in the sense of "why" or "for what purpose"):
    What is Jessore famous for?

(c) Which

Used selectively for persons, things, and lower animals in both Singular and Plural Numbers:

  • Which is his sister?
  • Which is the house?
4 Important Grammatical Rules for Interrogative Pronouns:
  1. Indirect Questions: Interrogative Pronouns are also used to ask Indirect Questions. In that case, the sentence becomes a Complex Sentence and ends with a Full Stop (.) instead of a Question Mark (?):
    • I know what he wants.
    • He asked who was crying.
    • Tell me which pen you would like to buy.
  2. Interrogative Pronouns vs. Interrogative Adjectives: When a Noun sits directly after which, what, or whose, they become Interrogative Adjectives:
    Interrogative Pronouns Interrogative Adjectives
    What is the matter? What matter is it?
    Which of the colours do you like? Which colours do you like?
  3. Auxiliary Verb Before Subject: When a direct question begins with an Interrogative Pronoun (as object), an Auxiliary Verb must be placed before the Subject:
    Incorrect: What he want? → Correct: What does he want?
    Incorrect: Whom you met? → Correct: Whom did you meet?
  4. Detached Prepositions: When who, what, or which is used as the Object of a Preposition, that Preposition is often placed separately at the end of the sentence. It is then called a Detached Preposition:
    • Who (whom) are you talking about?
    • What is Jessore famous for?
    • Who (whom) are you looking for?
    • Which of the pens did you buy to write with?
    However, if the Preposition is placed at the beginning of the sentence, whom must be used instead of who:
    • For whom are you looking?

6. Practice Exercise: Relative & Interrogative Pronouns

Identify whether the bold/used pronouns in the following sentences from the text are Relative, Conjunctive, or Interrogative Pronouns:

  1. Listen to what your teachers say.
  2. What is lotted can not be blotted.
  3. We can not do whatever we like.
  4. There is no man but wishes to be happy.
  5. This is the woman who lost her bag.
  6. The boy whom you met yesterday is my brother.
  7. The boy whose pen was lost was poor.
  8. I took a cabin which was small.
  9. We want such men as are active.
  10. These are the books that have just arrived.
  11. What does he do in the room?
  12. Who has broken the glass?
  13. Which of the pens did he buy?
  14. Whom did you see?
  15. What is Jessore famous for?
Click to Show Answers
  1. what — Conjunctive / Compound Relative Pronoun.
  2. What — Compound Relative Pronoun.
  3. whatever — Compound Relative Pronoun.
  4. but — Negative Relative Pronoun (= who does not).
  5. who — Relative Pronoun (Antecedent: woman).
  6. whom — Relative Pronoun in Objective Case (Antecedent: boy).
  7. whose — Relative Pronoun in Possessive Case (Antecedent: boy).
  8. which — Relative Pronoun (Antecedent: cabin).
  9. as — Relative Pronoun (after such).
  10. that — Relative Pronoun (Antecedent: books).
  11. What — Interrogative Pronoun.
  12. Who — Interrogative Pronoun (Nominative Case).
  13. Which — Interrogative Pronoun.
  14. Whom — Interrogative Pronoun (Objective Case).
  15. What — Interrogative Pronoun (with detached preposition for).